Comparing Leadership-Relevant Psychological Attributes Between Military School and Non-Military School Students

Main Article Content

G K Ashwin
Suresh Chandra Padhy

Abstract

This study looks at whether there is a measurable difference between the psychological attributes of military and non-military schooling in regard to attributes that are important to leadership development. A 30 item, six constructs, cross sectional comparative design was used where 450 students (259 from Military Schools and 191 from Non-Military Schools, Classes IX-XII) completed a questionnaire (30 items) of the following constructs: self-efficacy, resilience, emotional intelligence, cognitive competence, social preference and perceived leadership behaviour. The data were analysed using independent-samples t-tests, Cohen's d effect sizes, post-hoc power analysis, chi-square test of association, one-way ANOVA and Pearson correlation. There were 10 items (33%) that showed an important difference between the groups with statistically significant differences in that item, with a majority of these effects being small in magnitude, and mostly in the domain of action-oriented behaviours (motivation, decisive action, inspiring others) favouring the Military students, while a smaller number of items favoured the Non-Military students (believing in achieving goals, learning agility). Construct-level scores were very similar when computed (ratios ranging from 0.99 to 1.03) on each of the six constructs. Overall, the findings indicate no clear support for the uniform leadership advantage model for military pattern schooling and do support a model of an advantage by item with specific implications for curriculum design and implementation in the NEP 2020.

Article Details

Section

Articles