The Economic Impact of Artificial Intelligence on Copyright Societies: A Comparative Study of India, the United Kingdom and the United States
Main Article Content
Abstract
Generative Artificial Intelligence is transforming the economic landscape of copyright industries and challenging the traditional financial and institutional functioning of copyright societies. The ability of AI systems to access, process, reproduce and generate content using vast datasets of copyrighted works has created new economic opportunities as well as significant challenges for collective rights management. The use of copyrighted works in AI training, often without transparent disclosure or established licensing arrangements, raises fundamental questions concerning revenue generation, licensing expenditure, royalty collection, distribution mechanisms and the long-term financial sustainability of copyright societies.
This paper examines the economic impact of Artificial Intelligence on copyright societies through a comparative study of India, the United Kingdom and the United States with particular reference to the Indian Copyright Act, 1957, and the corresponding legal and institutional frameworks in the UK and USA, it analyses how AI is reshaping the economic models of collective rights management the study focuses on the economic implications of AI training and text and data mining, the emergence of new licensing markets, the costs of copyright monitoring and infringement detection, the efficiency of royalty administration, the valuation of copyrighted works and the distribution of economic benefits between creators, copyright societies and AI developers it also examines the implications of Section 52 of the Indian Copyright Act, 1957,for the economic exploitation of copyrighted works in AI training, alongside the broader questions of human authorship, synthetic content, cross-border exploitation and the absence of established AI-specific licensing tariffs and royalty mechanisms.
The paper argues that Artificial Intelligence presents a dual economic impact on copyright societies. On the one hand, AI-driven technologies have the potential to reduce administrative and transaction costs, improve copyright identification, enhance licensing efficiency and facilitate more accurate royalty distribution. On the other hand, unauthorised or inadequately compensated use of copyrighted works for AI training may undermine traditional licensing revenues, weaken the bargaining position of creators and create uncertainty regarding the future economic sustainability of collective management organisations. The paper further argues that the economic viability of copyright societies will increasingly depend on their ability to adapt their licensing structures, develop transparent AI-related revenue models and establish effective mechanisms for the identification, valuation and remuneration of copyrighted works. Through a comparative legal and economic analysis of India, the UK and the USA, the study proposes a framework for strengthening the financial sustainability, economic efficiency and institutional effectiveness of copyright societies while maintaining a fair balance between technological innovation and the economic interests of creators.